Choosing Between a Weld Bead and Weld Fillet in SOLIDWORKS

How to Normalize Mitered Tube Cuts on SOLIDWORKS Weldments

Table of Contents

Looking for a tutorial on normalizing coped tube cuts for manufacture? You’ve come to the right place. Modeling a mitered tube cut is done with the click of a button in SOLIDWORKS Weldments, but preparing the geometry for laser cutting or similar processes can be involved. We’ll run through a few methods on how to represent these manufacturing processes in SOLIDWORKS.

To see how to normalize coped cuts, check out our SOLIDWORKS Coped Cuts how-to article.

Before and AfterBefore and After

Using the Standard Method for Normalizing Mitered Tube Cuts on SOLIDWORKS Weldments

The ideal way to create a normalized end cut is trimming the outer tube surface and offsetting it inward using the Thicken command. This extrudes the outer surface normal to the tube axis. If the outer tube surface is not an acceptable reference, examine the other methods in this article. This method should work for a mitered cut at one end and a straight cut on the other, or for a mitered cut on either end if the steps are applied to both ends.

Because of the inflection point (as pictured above – for more information see the end of this article), half of the end face must reference the inner surface while the other half must reference the outer.

Step 1 – Create a Ruled Surface

We’ll begin with the inner surface. First, isolate the tube and launch the Ruled Surface command from the Surfaces tab of the CommandManager.

Ruled Surface in the CommandManagerRuled Surface in the CommandManager

In the PropertyManager, select “Normal to Surface” for Type, then activate the Edge Selection box (pink). Locate the cuts that need to be normalized and select their inner edge. This will create a surface that is normal to the tube axis and coincident with the inner edge. Lastly, ensure the Distance/Direction exceeds the outer wall of the tube. Both checkboxes in the Options field should be cleared. Click OK to accept and create the surface.

Ruled Surface PropertyManagerRuled Surface PropertyManager

A ruled surface can be thought of as sweeping a line segment around a given path. When we select the “Normal to Surface” option, we are constraining the ‘line’ to be perpendicular to the axis of the tube. For this reason, the same result can also be achieved by selecting the “Perpendicular to Vector” option and choosing the tube axis as the vector.

Step 2 – Delete Faces

Next, activate the Delete Face command from the Surfaces tab of the CommandManager.

Delete Face in the CommandManagerDelete Face in the CommandManager

In the Delete Face PropertyManager, ensure the “Show Selection Toolbar” option is checked and Options is set to “Delete”.

Delete Face PropertyManagerDelete Face PropertyManager

Select the INNER tube surface and do not move the mouse. A context-sensitive window pops up giving quick shortcuts for group selection. Choose the “All outer and inner loops” group selection.

Important: this should highlight ALL surfaces on the tube except the outer surface and ruled surface. If it does not, toggle the selection options or manually select the surfaces to complete this step.

Delete Face SelectionDelete Face Selection

Delete these surfaces by clicking OK. Again, check that only the outer surface and ruled surface remain.

Outer Surface and Ruled Surface (Color Added for Clarity)Outer Surface and Ruled Surface (Color Added for Clarity)

Step 3 – Trim the Outer Surface

Activate the Trim Surface command from the Surfaces tab of the CommandManager.

Trim Surface in the CommandManagerTrim Surface in the CommandManager

In the PropertyManager, select “Standard” for Trim Type, then activate the Trim Tool selection box and choose the ruled surface as the Trimming Surface. Toggle to the “Keep Selections” option and click the main body of the outer surface.

Trim Surface PropertyManagerTrim Surface PropertyManager

Trim the surface by clicking OK. This should create a small inflection on the end of the tube surface. The ruled surface can be removed using the Delete/Keep Body command.

Outer SurfaceOuter Surface

Step 4 – Thicken Surface

Lastly, select the outer surface body and use the Thicken command to extrude to the desired wall thickness. Merge result does not need to be checked.

Thicken in the CommandManagerThicken in the CommandManager

The Thicken command works by creating a normal offset surface and closing the volume with normalized end faces, so in effect the cut has been normalized!

Normalized CutNormalized Cut

Using Alternative Methods for Normalizing Mitered Tube Cuts on SOLIDWORKS Weldments

If deleting faces is out of the question for whatever reason, then we can employ another method to cut back the end of the tube to reference surfaces. This can be done with the powerful Replace Face command.

Step 1 – Create Ruled Surfaces

The first step in this method is the same as Step 1 in the Standard Method, so review those steps and return here. After that, a second ruled surface must be made in the same fashion but this time referencing the OUTER surface edge in the Edge Selection box. The result should look like the picture below.

Ruled Surfaces Ruled Surfaces

Step 2 – Create Split Line

In the Standard Method, the inflection point is made by trimming the outer surface to a reference surface. The nature of this second method requires that we create this inflection point first before modifying the end face. We’ll do this using a Split Line.

Activate the Split Line command.

Split Line in the CommandManagerSplit Line in the CommandManager

In the Property Manager, the Type of Split is “Intersection”, the Splitting Surface (pink) is the ruled surface coming from the INNER edge, and the Face to Split (blue) is the end face. The image below shows only the relevant ruled surface for clarity.

Split Line PropertyManagerSplit Line PropertyManager

Click OK to accept, and verify that the end of the tube has been split into two faces.

Step 3 – Replace Face

The Replace Face makes light work of modifying the end of the tube, but it requires an additional ruled surface, so be sure to follow these steps carefully.

Begin by activating the Replace Face command from the Surfaces tab of the CommandManager.

Replace Face in the CommandManagerReplace Face in the CommandManager

In the PropertyManager, select the ‘upper’ half of the tube face as the “Target for replacement” and select the ruled surface touching the INNER edge as the “Replacement surface”, as shown below. Click OK to replace this half of the end face.

Repeat the command making the opposite selections – the ‘lower’ half of the end face, and the ruled surface touching the OUTER edge – and click OK to replace.

Time-saving tip: This can be done in one Replace Face command, so long as the order in which the Target Faces are chosen matches the order in which the Replacement Surfaces are chosen. 

Replace Face SelectionsReplace Face Selections

Now the surface bodies can be removed using Delete/Keep Body, and the cut has been normalized!

Additional Information

If you are familiar with normalizing coped cuts, you’ll find that this process requires some extra steps. This is due to an inflection point that occurs where the leading surface of the mitered cut switches from the inner surface of the tube to the outside. This complicates the normalization process because half of the end face must reference the inner surface while the other half must reference the outer, so two separate modifications must be made.

Inflection PointInflection Point

If the Replace Face method does not work, then a more robust method using Cut with Surface can be employed. Watch our short video on how to create a coped cut perpendicular to a pipe and make sure to watch until the end for tons of troubleshooting tips.

Get More Training for SOLIDWORKS Modeling and Weldments

Want to know more? Get world-class training from our highly qualified live instructors. We offer a variety of courses including:

SOLIDWORKS – Surface Modeling Course 

SOLIDWORKS – Weldments Course 

If you have other questions or needs for engineering services, please contact our team and visit us at hawkridgesys.com.

Nick Keglovits

Nick Keglovits

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
solidworks cad dual monitors

Free Upgrades on SOLIDWORKS